Car Service City Logo

Car Service City

Unclaimed Business
|1.7
96 Reviews (last 12 months)
Does not respond to reviews

Scores reflect the Overall AI Score for each category

AI Review Summary

Based on recent customer reviews, Car Service City is described overwhelmingly through failed repairs and disputed accountability. Customers consistently report vehicles leaving branches in worse condition than they arrived, with new noises, seized engines, missing bolts and unresolved faults. A recurring theme is the struggle to obtain reports, callbacks or ownership from branches and head office, although isolated branches and named advisors receive genuine, repeat praise.

Top Strengths:

  • •Staff Professionalism & Conduct: The relatively strongest theme, carried by a small group of named advisors such as Rynhard, Louis, Ricky, Daniel and Juliet who customers describe as welcoming, honest and informative. This praise is heavily outweighed by reports of dismissive managers and rude complaints staff.
Service Quality Ratings
Industry Avg: 2.5Best: 4.5 (The Bakkie Shop)
Industry Avg: 2.4Best: 4.5 (Drive.co.za)
Industry Avg: 2.7Best: 4.5 (Koos and Mike Detailed Cars)
Overall AI Score
1.2
Industry Avg: 3Best: 4.7 (Botha & Deysel Executive Motors)
4.5-5 Excellent
3.5-4.5 Great
2.5-3.5 Average
1.5-2.5 Poor
<1.5 Terrible
Performance(last 12 months):
Trustindex Rating
2.4
NPS Score
-67Unlikely
Review Distribution
1.7|96 Reviews

Dec '25 - Nov '26

Frequently Asked Questions About Car Service City

What do customers say about Car Service City?

Based on recent customer reviews, Car Service City is described overwhelmingly through failed repairs and disputed accountability. Customers consistently report vehicles leaving branches in worse condition than they arrived, with new noises, seized engines, missing bolts and unresolved faults. A recurring theme is the struggle to obtain reports, callbacks or ownership from branches and head office, although isolated branches and named advisors receive genuine, repeat praise.

What is Car Service City's biggest strength?

Car Service City's biggest strength, according to Hellopeter's AI analysis, is Staff Professionalism & Conduct. The relatively strongest theme, carried by a small group of named advisors such as Rynhard, Louis, Ricky, Daniel and Juliet who customers describe as welcoming, honest and informative. This praise is heavily outweighed by reports of dismissive managers and rude complaints staff.

What are the most common complaints about Car Service City?

The most common complaint about Car Service City, based on Hellopeter's AI analysis of recent customer reviews, is Vehicle Quality & Reliability. Customers repeatedly describe engines seizing, gearboxes failing, coolant replaced with water and safety critical parts left unfitted. Warranty on workmanship is frequently refused, and generic parts fitted to specialist vehicles create fresh breakdowns and towing costs.

Is Car Service City trustworthy?

Car Service City has a TrustIndex of 2.4 out of 10 on Hellopeter, based on 96 reviews in the last 12 months. Hellopeter has tracked Car Service City across 1,087 total reviews. How is the TrustIndex calculated? →

Recent reviews (96)

Used this business recently? Share your experience to help others decide.

Share Your Experience
JJ
Jasmin J

1 reviews | Active since Apr 2024

17 Nov 2026, 15:13

Car Service City Craighall - JD - avoid at all costs

Very terrible experience With Craighall branch - specifically JD I had issues with my vehicle and trusted that a big brand like Car Service city would be honest and transparent I had my gearbox serviced with them and also replaced ECU , totalling almost R30000 (since August 2026) Still my vehicle is not reliable as it goes into limp mode randomly which I let JD know as soon as it happened I brought my vehicle in again on Monday as I saw a leak I was quoted a whopping R32000. I requested pictures of the items that they quoted on and also exact part codes and details as to what work would be done to justify the cost. The next morning JD requested that I rather collect my vehicle as he can't assist me. Simply for asking detailed questions BIG RED FLAG !!!!

0
Replies (0)
More
SL
SHONISANI L

1 reviews | Active since Sept 2025

11 Nov 2026, 17:55

Worst service by car service city

I took my car for service at car service city pretoria, they did major service on my car anD also replaced gear box mounting, after installing the car vibrating excessively which I explained and the response was it will be okay after 3 weeks later, after 3 days while driving the cv joint on right side came off. Whereas I did major service. I suspect the gearbox mounting caused all these as it did cause a sound while reversing and I took it back , they replaced 3 days after service cv joint came off while driving . Take your car to car service city at your own risk

0
Replies (0)
More
CB
Christiaan B

1 reviews | Active since Nov 2026

11 Nov 2026, 07:38

Unacceptable

I would strongly advise anyone considering using this company to stay well clear. I have had an absolutely horrific experience with their Loop Street branch recently. The workmanship has been completely unacceptable. Not only did they fail to resolve the issues I originally brought the vehicle in for, but following a second inspection, it was discovered that they had not even completed all the work they had charged me for. What makes the experience even worse is the appalling customer service. The complaints department could not have been more indifferent or unemotional when dealing with the situation. There was absolutely no empathy, accountability or regard for me as a customer. It is clear that customer satisfaction is simply not a priority. The level of incompetence, poor workmanship and complete lack of accountability is extremely disappointing. Let this serve as a warning to anyone considering using their services. I would certainly not recommend them.

1
Replies (1)
More
DU
Delton U

1 reviews | Active since Nov 2026

10 Nov 2026, 11:26

I am very happy with the service I received at Car Service City, Northmead

I am very happy with the service I received at Car Service City, Northmead. The staff were friendly, calm and professional. They treated me well, explained everything and made sure my car was taken care of. I really appreciate their good customer service and the way they handled everything. I would definitely recommend Car Service City to anyone looking for reliable service. Keep up the good work! 👏😊

1
Replies (0)
More
WW
Wendy W

1 reviews | Active since Mar 2026

10 Nov 2026, 11:15

Costly experience

Extremely disappointing experience at Car Service City, Stonewood I took my vehicle to Car Service City at Stonewood for a routine service. The original quotation was approximately R4,500, but I ended up paying over R8,000. Unfortunately, the experience has been extremely disappointing. Immediately after collecting my vehicle, I noticed a new zinging or ringing noise coming from the engine, which had not been there before the service. I was also informed by the branch that a staff member had damaged something on the fuel line. Since then, I have been advised that the high-pressure fuel pump may be leaking petrol into the engine oil and may need replacing. The oil and oil filter may also need to be replaced again due to possible petrol contamination. The exact mechanical cause still needs to be confirmed, but these concerns have arisen following the service and subsequent work at the branch. To make matters worse, the invoice does not clearly explain what work was actually carried out, leaving me with unanswered questions about what was done to my vehicle. I have completely lost confidence in this branch and would not be comfortable allowing them to work on my vehicle again. I am extremely disappointed that what should have been a routine service has turned into an expensive and stressful experience. I would not recommend the Stonewood branch based on my experience.

1
Replies (0)
More
MP
Michael P

1 reviews | Active since Jan 2018

6 Nov 2026, 11:12

Worst ever service.

Took my car for an inspection on 05/11 to Heathfield Branch aCape Town.There was noise coming from the engine. I shared with them where I think it was coming from. I get a quote for R36k for repairs and get told that they were not able to establish where the noise comes from but if I repair as per quote they can then assess. I was told and according to there papers they will not work on or remove anything on the car before informing me. They removed the intake manifold ( Audi) because they picked up a fault on the number 2 injector and wanted to inspect it. I was not informed they were removing anything and was told they did this out of goodwill. My coolant level was low and I had to ask them to top it up. I never had problem before. By the time I got home it was empty and they tell me they don't know if there was a water leak cause they did not check for leaks. I now have a massive miss fire. From driving 120km on the freeway to get to them and then after they checked the car it goes into limp mode, misfire, no coolant and the manager speaks to me as if he was doing me a favor and so arrogant. The issue I went in for was not evennidentified. They are the worst to deal with. Pity I did not check the reviews first. Can't understand how they get a high google review rating.

1
Replies (0)
More
NH
Nobuhle H

1 reviews | Active since May 2024

2 Nov 2026, 11:09

URGENT!

To whom it may concern I am writing this email with utter disappointment in the Benoni Lakeside Car Service City. On March, 19th of 2026, I did a major service on my Toyota Etois that costed around R4500, and then on top of that they found out my clutch is worn off. I paid for the new clutch kit to be installed as well as wheel alignment and everything else. Everything costed around R13k. My new clutch had a certain sound, I went back they told me that "new clutches have that sound until a certain period of time", now TELL ME HOW a "new clutch kit" can now be expired. On the 30th of October 2026 my clutch cable tore while I was driving in the middle of the round, swerved on the nearest pavement. I called a towing truck that costed me R3000 to take me home and called a local family Mechanic to check what is wrong, he mentioned that it was just a clutch cable torn. LITTLE DID I KNOW! I bought the clutch cable Saturday for R700 and had it installed. Everything was installed properly, now my gear can't get into the gears and I can't even press my clutch pedal. Sooooooo all the money I have spent there has gone down the drain as now I went there today, 02 October 2026, I am therefore being told that I should bring my car there!!!HOW WHEN MY CAR CANNOT GET INTO GEARS AND MY CLUTCH IS NOT WORKING WHEREAS. Soooooo I am disappointed in your service centre and therefore taking further actions into hands as Section 54 of South Africa's Consumer Protection Act addresses MY right to receive services performed to an acceptable standard. AS A BLACK SINGLE WOMAN IN SOUTH AFRICA WE ARE SUFFERING!

0
Replies (0)
More
SF
Soehayma F

1 reviews | Active since Nov 2026

1 Nov 2026, 09:49

They rip people off and do not do a good job. Don't use them

Please don't take your car to these people they rip you off and they don't do a proper job. i will never take my car there again.

1
Replies (0)
More